Considering how many f&c places there are in Otley, my preference is another vote for the Little Fisherman in Yeadon. They fry in dripping, which is not to everybody’s liking, but the flavour is superb.
The Wooden Hut (opposite Prince Henry’s school) in Otley can be top notch, but tends to blow hot and cold.
I’ve always fancied trying the chippies on Silver Street in Whitby. It has a bit of a fearsome reputation, but has limited opening hours, which unforunately have never coincided with any time I’ve been in the town. I’ve tried many of the other places, but have never been overwhelmed with their offerings.